96 points, Dave Brookes, Halliday Wine Companion
A gorgeous shiraz sourced from the 1915 plantings of the Helbig family vineyard in Greenock. It sings true to its western Barossa roots with a ferruginous edge, and this release seems to have a little more detail and light than the previous model. It's at the lighter end of full-bodied and sits flush with fruit tones of doris plum, black cherry and blackberry fruits, etched with hints of baking spices, cedar, roasting meats, grilled fig, dark chocolate, plum conserve, fruitcake, purple florals and turned earth. Harmonious and elegant in its travel, with ironstone-edge, powdery tannins and a fine, lacy acidity that lends a freshness and velocity to that lovely pure fruit.
95 points - Andrew Caillard MW, The Vintage Journal
Medium-deep crimson. Lifted musky plum, dark chocolate aromas with
sesame, marzipan notes. Fresh dark plum, blackberry spice flavours
with intense cedar/ marzipan. Mocha oak notes and sinuous chocolaty
tannins. Finishes spicy/ cedary with espresso notes. Oak-dominant
wine, but should settle down. Drink 2026–2036
95 points, Erin Larkin, The Wine Advocate
The 2023 Helbig 1915 Shiraz remains a statuesque and powerful wine, but it is not as big or concentrated as last year's wine. I like both. Here, the wine is savory and spicy, with notes of sandalwood and clove, forest floor and aged leather, alongside the bright fruit notes of mulberry, blackberry and raspberry. In the mouth, the tannins are pliable and profuse, but I like the way they shape the fruit. The wine was fermented in French puncheons. This is a change from the early vintages, which were fermented in 1,500-liter closed-vat fermenters that trapped the alcohol and produced very big wines. This evolution means that the wine today, while substantial, is balanced and fresh. The Helbig family planted and farmed this 1915 planting for three generations, and now the Ashmeads own it (since 2010). Don Helbig still visits the vineyard occasionally, and the family maintains a good relationship with him. 700 bottles filled. 14.8% alcohol, sealed under natural cork.